My dad shared his old list and mine (not
that old - 11 years) a couple of weeks ago, and mine had changed enough that it's worth doing again.
So, revised for 2020 (and in chronological order by release date, which isn't necessarily when it mattered to me)...
Christmas Album, Herb Alpert & the Tijuana Brass (1968)
We may or may not have bought our current house because it suited this record better than our old house. It is everything that makes festive seasons festive. Which mostly involves reindeer chorus lines and the aesthetic of "The Best Things Happen While You're Dancing" which is not, in fact, a song on this record.
Aqualung, Jethro Tull (1971)
Jethro Tull is the band I've seen live the most times. More than Live! More than the Indigo Girls, and they play parks and stuff now! What I said 11 years ago is still true - this record is my dad's deep and abiding impact on my musical taste & questioning perspective on the world. I still love the liner notes.
Double Fantasy, John Lennon & Yoko Ono (1980)
Sounds like lullabies from my parents, or sleeping in the living room so it'd be easy to get up for an early morning field trip. I have incredibly sentimental feelings about this album.
Concert in Central Park, Simon & Garfunkel (1981)
I don't remember a time when this album didn't exist! This concert was so long ago. But I still giggle at the joke about the guys selling loose joints, just before they launch into "America" and all these songs could rock me to sleep again today.
Temple of Low Men, Crowded House (1988)
This might have been the first record I was truly obsessive about. If you listen really closely to "Better Be Home Soon" at the end, you can hear Neil Finn breathe. And yes. Kim and I were the kind of teeens who'd want to listen to a good singer breathe.
Mental Jewelry, Live (1991)
If Exile in Guyville was the gateway to all the riot grrrl stuff I liked, Live was the reason I managed to halfway enjoy the whole grunge tradition. They were not grunge, but they did play loud & it turns out I like loud. Sometimes. Particularly when the songs are so well-crafted.
The Stiff Records Box Set, everyone and their effing brother (1992)
Introduced me to Nick Lowe, Elvis Costello, Madness. Basically the entirety of 70s and 80s British alternative music. Very educational.
Exile in Guyville, Liz Phair (1993)
This was like my gateway album into Bikini Kill and Heavens to Betsy, when I'd mostly been listening to Indigo Girls and 10,000 Maniacs and assorted musicals. Liz Phair herself is not without issues, I know, but I acknowledge that my musical taste, my college life and my general sex- queer- body-positive feminism owes her.
Shaming of the Sun, Indigo Girls (1997)
I... did not love this album when it came out. It's the first album where they're really just unapologetically gay, and neither repressed nor depressed. In retrospect it's amazing that this album is over 20 years old, and it clicks with my adult emotions more than the earlier albums do.
Substrata, Biosphere (1997)
I had a therapist who told me to listen to ambient music to down-regulate my nervous system. He's also a drummer, and I suspect he meant that I should listen to "relaxing zen beats for rest and study" or something. Turns out ambient music full of semi-industrial and polar sounds cured my panic attacks, so... he was right.
Long Knives Drawn, Rainer Maria (2003)
I would take this album into an otherwise music-less solitary confinement and still be surprisingly contented. It manages to accomplish many sounds within a vague "Chicago early oughts indie rock" aesthetic. Also it's a natural development from my affection for Bikini Kill and Melissa Etheridge.
Give Up, The Postal Service (2003)
I ran into this at a particularly rich and creative time (a bit after it was released) and was so delighted to discover I kinda like some electropop-ish music. The collaboration story behind this one is just SO GOOD, too. Speaking of collaboration...
A Mark, A Mission, A Brand, A Scar, Dashboard Confessional (2003)
He is so very good at evoking certain feelings that I often forget this album came out as late as it did.
PS - In a weird way, I count this as an REM album thanks to Chris Carrabba and Michael Stipe playing together on MTV Unplugged. So, even though REM is the essence of Gen X SouthernUSness, I don't have to include one of their records on this list.
The Sunset Tree, The Mountain Goats (2005)
Really the best album for sad times. The best.
Okemah & the Melody of Riot, Son Volt (2005)
Still my favorite Son Volt album, even though Jay keeps writing excellent tunes. A lot of it is music about music, so even though it's not happy per se, it's a reliable happy place
Matt Pond PA's Freeep (2008)
It's maybe not technically an album, but it's got my favorite song in the world on it (a song I love enough to have him write it down for my longhand as a reward for kickstarting a later album) and just makes me so happy any time I hear any of the songs. I think he announced this on MySpace. Matt hung on to MySpace longer than most.
One Fast Move or I'm Gone, Jay Farrar and Ben Gibbard (and, I suppose, Jack Kerouac, 2009)
Generally, Beat poets are a thing I love. Except for Kerouac. I've never enjoyed any of his writing. But. I truly truly love irascible Jay Farrar's songwriting talent, and Ben Gibbard's voice. And I think they both bring a healthier sensibility and affection to Kerouac's words.
A Mulher o Fim do Mundo, Elza Soares (2015)
After years and years of most of my non-English-lyrics music being for dance purposes, this album was an excellent punch in the face. I have a much broader appreciation of music from around the world now - which I also owe to a radio program called
Global-a-go-go (yes, from the Joe Strummer record)
Radnor & Lee, Eponymous (2017)
Ben Lee makes some very strange musical art. This art is not that strange, but is kindof a middle aged spiritual quest buddy movie of an album. It's full of joy. You probably haven't heard it, but you might like it.
Designer, Aldous Harding (2019)
Most of the time I don't know what Aldous Harding means. I like that - most of pop music isn't open to artistic interpretation. This album, and all her videos, also changed the way we dance in our house.
( And the original 2009 list )1. Aqualung, Jethro Tull
2. Swamp Ophelia, Indigo Girls
3. Chess, the London original cast recording
4. Such Great Heights EP, Postal Service
5. We Will Become Like Birds, Erin Mckeown
6. Yell Fire, Michael Franti/Spearhead
7. Gulag Orkestar, Beirut
8. Awake is the New Sleep, Ben Lee
9. Like a Virgin, Madonna
10. My Solo Project, Mates of State
11. Long Knives Drawn, Rainer Maria
12. Temple of Low Men, Crowded House
13. Narrow Stairs, Death Cab for Cutie
14. 6 String Drag (eponymous)
15. Okemah & the Melody of Riot, Son Volt
16. Zeppelin III, Led Zeppelin
17. Several Arrows Later, Matt Pond PA
18. The Stiff Records Box Set, everyone and their effing brother
19. Double Fantasy, John Lennon & Yoko Ono
20. Furnace Room Lullaby, Neko Case & Her Boyfriends